For most small businesses that want new customers who don’t already know them, yes. In our worked examples, at an entry-level hosting price, a simple site of your own costs roughly the same over three years as a basic pay-monthly deal or a directory listing, and at the end you still own it. We sell both ways: website packages, or our Monthly Plan, so weigh our view with that in mind. But a website isn’t worth it for everyone: if you’re fully booked from referrals, or a platform listing already brings in all the work you want, it can wait.
So “is a website worth it for a small business?” has an honest answer for your business, and it comes down to two things: do you want more or different customers, and will the site cost less than the work it helps bring in?
Key takeaways
- A website is worth it when you want new customers who find you by searching, or you rely on one app or account you don’t control.
- It’s not worth it yet if your diary is full from word of mouth, a listing already does the job, or you’re still testing the idea.
- Over three years, a simple owned site on entry-level hosting and a basic pay-monthly deal cost similar amounts in our worked examples. After that, the owned site costs far less each year.
- If you’re not sure, start with a free Google Business Profile, then decide.
Is a website worth it for a small business? A quick test
Answer these honestly:
- Do you want more customers, or different ones (bigger jobs, a new area, a new service)?
- Do new customers usually find you by searching, rather than by being told about you?
- Do people keep asking you the same things: prices, hours, areas covered, parking?
- Does most of your work come through one app, account or directory you don’t control?
- Could you make back the cost from a handful of extra customers a year?
Mostly yes: a website is very likely worth it. Mostly no: read the “when it isn’t worth it” section below before spending anything.
What a website really costs over three years
Compare three-year totals, not a monthly fee against a one-off price. This is a worked example, not a quote. It uses prices advertised on providers’ own pages when we checked, except hosting, which you fill in from your own host’s page.
| Route | How the sum works | 3-year total |
|---|---|---|
| Own site, paid once | £1,500 build (assumed) + hosting at £[your host’s monthly price] × 36 + .co.uk domain £9.59 × 3 | £1,528.77 plus 36 months of hosting |
| Pay monthly | Entry packages we saw: £35 to £79 a month × 36, before any price rises | £1,260 to £2,844 |
| DIY website builder | £20 a month including VAT after the intro offer, plus a domain | about £750, plus your evenings |
| Directory listing only | A basic plan at £30 plus VAT (£36) a month × 36 | £1,296, and no website of your own |
Two things change the picture after year three:
- The owned site gets cheap to keep. In the example above, year four costs the hosting and domain: 12 months of hosting plus £9.59. The pay-monthly examples carry on at £420 to £948 a year for as long as you want the site online.
- What you have if you stop paying. With an owned site, the site, domain and content stay yours. With a listing, the paid features stop when the payments stop, and what’s left, if anything, depends on the directory’s terms. With pay monthly, it depends on the contract.
Our guides on pay monthly vs paying once and website running costs go through these sums in more detail.
Will it pay for itself?
Here’s the sum that matters to you. It’s an example, so swap in your own figure.
Say one new customer is worth £150 to you after costs. The owned site above costs £1,528.77 plus 36 months of hosting over three years. Divide that total by £150 to see how many such customers would cover it in three years, and by 3 again for a year. If one decent job, one regular client or one weekly order would cover that, a website is a small bet. If your typical customer is worth a lot less and you’d need dozens a year, look harder at the cheaper routes.
Nobody can promise how many customers a website will bring, and Google says there’s no way to pay for a better local ranking. What a site does is give people who look you up a clear page with what you do, where, and how to get in touch.
Is it worth it for your kind of business?
Trades: plumbers, electricians, gardeners
Usually yes. When a boiler breaks or a job comes up, a customer who doesn’t know you yet wants to see what you do, where you cover and a number to ring. A simple four or five page site does that job, and it’s yours whether or not you also pay for a directory. See what a tradesperson’s website costs and our page on websites for plumbers and heating engineers.
Maybe not if you’re booked months ahead from builders and repeat customers and don’t want more work.
Salons, barbers and dog groomers
Often yes, but a small one. Instagram shows your work and a booking app fills your diary, but both are rented. A few pages with your prices and a “Book now” button that goes to the app you already use gives you something you own. Our guide on whether you need a website if you’re on Instagram covers this in full.
Maybe not if you’re a one-chair business with a full book and a waiting list.
Cafés
Usually yes. A menu, opening hours and a map that anyone can open without an app are what most visitors are after, and they’re easy to keep in one place on your own site.
Maybe not if nearly all your trade is passing footfall and your Google Business Profile already shows the right hours.
Clinics, physios and accountants
Usually yes. New clients choosing someone to trust with their health or their money may want to check who you are before they get in touch: your qualifications, your approach, and how to book or enquire. That’s hard to lay out on a social profile.
Maybe not if you only work with a small, settled client list or through one referral partner.
Tutors and one-person services
It depends. If a listing platform brings enough students or clients and you’re happy with its fees, a website can wait. If you want to be found by your own name, or to stop paying commission on repeat clients, a simple site helps.
When a website isn’t worth it (yet)
Be honest with yourself. A website probably isn’t worth paying for right now if:
- You’re fully booked from referrals and you aren’t looking to grow, raise prices or change the work you do.
- A platform listing is enough. A directory, booking app or marketplace brings all the work you want, and you’re comfortable with its terms. Our guide on a trade directory or your own website looks at using both.
- You’re testing an idea and might not be trading in a year. Keep costs low until you know.
- You won’t keep it up to date. A site with last year’s prices and wrong opening hours can send people the wrong way. If you can’t give it a few minutes when things change, wait until you can.
Not sure? Start free
Whatever you decide, set up a Google Business Profile. It’s free, and Google says businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local results. You can add your website to it later, and some types of business can add a link for appointments or reservations. Our Google Business Profile setup guide walks through it step by step.
Then come back to the quick test in a few months.
Common questions
Is it worth paying for a website if I have a Facebook or Instagram page?
It can be. Social pages are good for showing recent work, but you don’t control them, and not everyone uses them. A small site gives you one place you own, and you can link your social pages from it.
Is a free or DIY website good enough?
For some businesses, yes, especially at the start. The cost is your time, and you should check you can take the site with you if you ever leave the platform.
Free help
If you decide it’s worth it
We’re Hintling Studio, an independent web design studio registered in London. Every package includes starter content for your kind of business and SEO basics with Google Search Console set up. After launch there are 30 days of fixes on our work, then the site is yours to run.
See what’s in each package, or tell us about your business.
Hintling Studio is not connected with Google, Instagram or Facebook.
